Dishonesty during Discovery Examinations

by | May 2, 2012 | General Law Related

Dishonesty during Discovery Examinations

A recent court decision out of Alberta has stressed the importance of adhering to the oath taken prior to commencing an examination for discovery and giving the inquiring party truthful answers. In Security Bancorp Inc. v. Faria [2009] A.J. No. 845, Justice C.J. Kenny dealt with the issue of whether a party who lied under oath during an examination for discovery could be found in contempt of court.

The action arose out of breach of employment contract and breach of fiduciary duty. During his examination for discovery, the defendant specifically denied a number of allegations advanced by the plaintiff. Subsequent to the examination, the plaintiff was granted an order to obtain third party information, which clearly indicated that the defendant had lied in his testimony regarding issues which were pertinent to the action.

Justice Kenny found Mr. Faria in contempt of court based on his deceitful answers during the discovery. However, he did preface this finding by noting that the usual remedy in this circumstance would be to award costs against the deceitful party. It will only be in the ‘extremely rare’ occasion that a party will be found in civil contempt for lying in an examination for discovery, namely, when the deceitful answer is in relation to the main issue and not merely a ‘peripheral’ issue.

This ruling was intended to drive home the fact that examinations for discovery are an essential step in civil litigation. Distorting evidence during the examination can have serious legal ramifications; namely, being found in civil contempt. While Justice Kenny notes that awarding costs against a party who has abused the process is, and continues to be, the usual avenue taken by the courts, this case provides for an alternative, much more severe, sanction. The penalty for civil contempt can include a fine, imprisonment or possibly both. While this decision comes out of Alberta, the finding will likely be used by parties across the Provinces who seek to sanction those abusing the discovery process by giving deceitful answers.


Personal Injuries at Provincial Campgrounds

Personal Injuries in Provincial Parks – do you know what to do if you get hurt at a provincially run campground this summer? And what about deadlines? Learn who’s accountable and how quickly you need to consult with a lawyer.

Suing for Whiplash – A Pain in the Neck

Whiplash is perhaps the most common injury associated with auto collisions. But many insurance companies are suspicious of whiplash claims and will do anything to deny payment. Read the full article to learn more.

Personal Injury Claims & Social Media

Don’t Self-Sabotage on Social Media – the defence is looking to discredit you, and you might be giving them everything they need. Use social media responsibly during your trial so that your posts can’t be used against you – read the full article to learn more.

Slips, Trips & Falls – Business vs Private Residence

Where you had your accident can matter as much as why you got hurt. The Occupier’s Liability Act holds businesses and homes to different standards. Find out how this could affect your case, read the full article to learn more.

Bicycle Accidents and Personal Injuries

Cyclists assume way more risk than drivers. And if the two ever collide, the cyclist’s injuries could be serious and permanent. If you’ve been hurt in an accident involving a car or truck read the full article to learn more.

Loss of Limb – Potential Impacts to Lawsuit

The nature and severity of amputation make it unique among personal injury claims. Make sure you’re taking everything into consideration before submitting your claim – read the full article to learn more.

Dangerous Street Racing & Stunt Driving – Personal Injury Lawsuits

We’re already sharing the road with self-driving cars. But who’s at fault when they get involved in accidents that cause injuries to other drivers? And can you sue? Read the full article to learn more..

Personal Injury and the Canada Revenue Agency

If you win a personal injury lawsuit in Ontario, how much will you lose in taxes? How do you hold onto it and keep it out of the hands of the taxman? Click here to learn about tax-free structured annuities.

Autonomous Driving Accidents & Personal Injury

We’re already sharing the road with self-driving cars. But who’s at fault when they get involved in accidents that cause injuries to other drivers? And can you sue? Read the full article to learn more..

Personal Injury Claims & Accidents Involving Uber or Lyft Drivers

When ridesharing becomes accident-sharing – who’s responsible for injuries when Lyft and Uber drivers are involved in a crash? For simple answers to this complex and complicated question, click here for our comprehensive guide to ridesharing injuries.